Why Does New York State Sue Its College Students?
Amanda Belony was rushing to work when she saw a fat yellow envelope left for her on her mother’s kitchen table. She opened it and immediately …
Amanda Belony was rushing to work when she saw a fat yellow envelope left for her on her mother’s kitchen table. She opened it and immediately noticed the New York attorney general’s official seal sitting ominously at the top of the page. The state had filed a lawsuit against her for unpaid college tuition.
Ms. Belony had registered for classes at the State University of New York at Plattsburgh in the spring of 2016, when she was 21, but she’d had severe health problems the previous semester and could no longer afford to live in Plattsburgh to finish her degree. Because she missed the withdrawal deadline for the spring semester, she said, she was charged for classes she never took, and now New York State was suing her for $3,705.
The only way she could defend herself was to appear in State Supreme Court in Albany — a four-hour bus trip from her home in Brooklyn. If she failed to appear, the letter stated, a judgment would be entered against her.
Ms. Belony was working 10-hour days as a clerical assistant in a medical clinic at the time, making just enough to pay her bills and help her mother with the rent. Trips to Albany to try to defend herself would be expensive, and she worried she’d lose her job.
“I remember looking at this document, with all this legal jargon that I didn’t understand,” Ms. Belony said. She needed just three credits to graduate, but until she settled the case years later, she couldn’t re-enroll to finish her degree in hopes of getting a better-paying job. “I didn’t have the money. I knew I needed a lawyer, and I knew I couldn’t afford one.”
New York State sued Amanda Belony for $3,705 she incurred at SUNY Plattsburgh. “I remember looking at this document, with all this legal jargon that I didn’t understand,” she said.Credit…Thalia Juarez for The New York Times
Ms. Belony is one of close to 16,000 SUNY students taken to court by the state since 2013. Under a little-known state regulation, New York’s attorney general is allowed to sue students if a state public university claims they owe tuition — or overdue library fines or unpaid parking tickets.
Unlike almost all regulations governing the collection of debt, a quirk in the law allows the attorney general’s office to file suit in these cases exclusively in State Supreme Court in Albany, regardless of where the student lives or attended college. If a student from SUNY Buffalo, for example, which is 300 miles from Albany, doesn’t show up in court, a judge will rule in the state’s favor and declare the student in default. The student’s wages could be garnished or tax refund withheld.
A majority of these cases end in default, according to several lawyers who represent students, since most students can’t make the several trips to Albany that would be required before a trial is even set.
Attorney General Letitia James, who took office in 2019, has often spoken out in defense of students struggling with tuition debt; she has advocated for debt relief programs and has suspended SUNY debt collection during the pandemic.
Asked about the law that allows SUNY colleges to refer student debtors to her office, she responded that the attorney general has “a legal obligation to collect student debt.”
Although she did not say why lawsuits had been used so often to do so, she said her office was working on ways to change how debt is collected. Last week, she sent a letter to legislators proposing to work with them on overhauling the system. One suggestion was to give the attorney general’s office more flexibility in reaching settlements.
“This work is far from over,” Ms. James said in an email, “and we look forward to working with legislators and policymakers to reform student debt collection practices in New York so that all students can achieve the goal of higher education without the crushing burden of debt.”
The State University of New York is made up of 64 schools, including community colleges and research universities, spread throughout the state. Nearly 400,000 students were enrolled in the SUNY system last year. Its stated mission of providing a high-quality, affordable education has attracted people from a range of socioeconomic backgrounds. Yet many students struggle to pay tuition, even with loans and scholarships.
New York is one of five states — in addition to Virginia, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Louisiana — that permit public colleges to send overdue debts directly to the state attorney general for collection. New York State regulations do not require the attorney general to take up lawsuits against students. A spokeswoman for the attorney general’s office said that before filing suit, it sends the student three letters seeking payment.
“Litigation is an absolute last resort,” said the spokeswoman, Delaney Kempner, “as we give borrowers plenty of time to contest the debt at issue and ample opportunity to demonstrate any sort of hardship.”
Court records suggest otherwise. Between November 2019 and March 2020 alone, at least 110 students were sued within a year of when the college said they had incurred their debts. Some are sued immediately after leaving college. One student from SUNY Potsdam who, according to court records, owed money from the 2019 spring semester was sued for $2,435 in December 2019.
The decision to file the lawsuits in State Supreme Court in Albany has been a considerable barrier for students who don’t live nearby. Buffalo, which is home to two SUNY universities that enroll close to 30,000 undergraduates combined, is at least four hours by car from Albany and six hours by bus. SUNY Fredonia, on the shore of Lake Erie, is five hours by car and more than seven hours by public transportation.
In 2014, New York State enacted a consumer protection law that requires that debtors be sued in the county where they live. But medical debt and student debt are exempt from the law, despite objections by student advocates.
Still, the attorney general could decide to sue in counties other than Albany, which could make it easier for students to defend themselves.
“There’s no due process if they’re suing you in Albany,” said Johnson Tyler, a Brooklyn Legal Services lawyer who says he gets at least one call a week from someone who wants to finish a degree but can’t because of student debt. “How can you have due process when you have to get on a bus and travel hundreds of miles away, and you have to go again and again and again?”
Earlier this year, Assemblyman Harvey Epstein, a Democrat from Manhattan, introduced a bill that would require the attorney general’s office to sue students only in the county or city where they live.
“It’s ridiculous that students are being sued in Albany,” said Mr. Epstein, who also questions the practice of lawsuits as a means of collecting student debt. “It may be more convenient for the A.G.’s office, but it makes it almost impossible for low-income students to defend themselves. They can’t get to Albany, they can’t get a lawyer. We are really disadvantaging people who are already disadvantaged.”
Ms. Kempner, speaking on behalf of the attorney general, said that students who are sued have the initial option of disputing their cases electronically or by mail. But if the attorney general’s office decides to proceed with the case, the student or his or her lawyer must appear in Albany.
After several inquiries from The New York Times about why students are sued only in one Albany courthouse, Ms. Kempner said this week that the office planned to change the practice and file cases in different counties in the future.
The decision to sue in Albany has, over the years, put many students into default. Data provided by the attorney general’s office shows the high likelihood of default judgments: From 2017 through 2019, about 3,000 lawsuits were filed every year, with an average of 2,500 ending in default.
In fact, many students say they were unaware that they had even been sued. Carlotta Summers, who attended SUNY Fredonia, came to realize she had been sued only when the tax refund she was expecting in 2019 never appeared. Her refunds were also taken in 2015 and 2018, but she said she had assumed she made a mistake in filing.
But after it happened for a third time, she called the Civil Recoveries Bureau, which is part of the attorney general’s office, which told her that her refund had been withheld because she had been sued but wouldn’t say why. The court records weren’t online, and she said the county clerk at the Supreme Court in Albany wouldn’t send them to her. So her father sent a courier to Albany to get the court records. Only then did she discover that she had been sued for overdue tuition and that a default judgment had been entered against her when she failed to appear before the judge.
The university said she owed $7,000 from a semester she spent there in the spring of 2009, when she was 19. She said that she was unaware she owed money, and that her bill now stands at more than $20,000 because of interest and collection fees. She filed a motion to get the default judgment overturned, saying she would have appeared in court had she known she was being sued. The judge ruled against her, and she is appealing.
A SUNY Fredonia spokesman said in an email that the university couldn’t comment on individual cases but that its student accounts office tries to contact students to resolve unpaid bills with payment plans, to avoid sending them to the attorney general’s office.
“The amount I owe is more than the amount I make per year,” said Ms. Summers, 31, who works as a teaching assistant while she pursues a career in film. “I worry about it all the time. I lose sleep over it.”
Advocates say that Ms. Summers’s experience echoes those of other students overwhelmed by debt.
“In cases where students have fallen behind, you’re adding interest and fees on top of that,” said Anna Anderson, a lawyer at Legal Assistance of Western New York. On top of the original amount owed, as well as the interest and fees added by the college, the attorney general’s office can charge interest of up to 9 percent, more than twice the rate of federal student loans. According to court records, some students have seen their debt balloon by 40 percent or more in less than two years.
“You’re asking a student who had trouble paying their bills in the first place — maybe it was health issues or family issues or job loss — to pay more than they owed originally.”
Before the moratorium during the pandemic, the pace of lawsuits brought against SUNY students had been steadily increasing. From 2008 to 2012, the state filed an average of 1,250 lawsuits against students each year, according to data obtained through a Freedom of Information Law request. From 2018 to 2020, however, the average grew to 3,000 a year.
The increased pace of lawsuits has dovetailed with the rise of tuition at SUNY colleges. At the same time, student loans and grants have covered less of the cost of attending. Total cost of attendance at four-year SUNY colleges for in-state students currently averages more than $26,000 per year.
“For the past decade, prices have been going up, but the amount of funding students get has stayed flat, and that leaves a gap in their bills,” said Beth Todd, director of student accounts at SUNY Potsdam. “It’s also a question of financial literacy. Students who withdraw don’t always understand that after four weeks of classes, they’re on the hook for the whole bill.”
Putting aside the issue of whether the debt collection efforts of the attorney general’s office are fair to students, they appear to have had limited success. For example, in the year leading up to the pandemic, the total amount of student debt was $242.7 million. Only $11.8 million has been collected, according to data provided by the attorney general’s office.
The practice goes back nearly three decades, to a time when the state budget was under strain and efforts to collect debt were ramped up. In 1993, the state issued a regulation requiring all state agencies, including SUNY, to refer overdue debts to either a private collection agency or the attorney general’s office after 99 days.
SUNY then issued its own guidance, mandating the referral of debts between $500 and $9,999, owed after a semester, to a collection agency or the attorney general’s office. (Debts of $10,000 or more must be referred solely to the attorney general’s office.) The state can then choose to sue a student to recover the debt.
Like most universities, SUNY colleges will not release a student’s transcript or allow a student to re-enroll if a balance is overdue. Once a debt has been referred to the attorney general’s office, a student can no longer work with a campus financial aid counselor to find a solution. Administrators at some SUNY campuses use an alternative to legal action. Students at SUNY New Paltz, for example, are sued at a lower rate than those at some other colleges with enrollment of a similar size. About 75 New Paltz students have been sued since 2013, according to records obtained through a FOIL request.
The university manages to keep most of its collection efforts in-house, said Jeff Gant, vice president for enrollment management at New Paltz. The university uses a data alert system to find students who are behind on their bills and notify the student’s financial aid counselor and academic adviser, who then contact the student. The school also offers alumni-financed completion grants, usually between $1,000 and $5,000, to help students who are close to graduating but have run into financial hardship.
“Our focus is less about debt collection and more about trying to make sure students never get in that situation in the first place,” Mr. Gant said.
Ms. Belony says she wishes she had this kind of help.She never found a lawyer who could represent her. Without her degree, she said, she was consigned to a series of low-wage jobs with long hours. Her federal student loans also came due, and there were months when she barely made her rent.
“I was just really, really sad,” she said. “I always had it in my head that I was going to go to college. My mom was drilling into me the importance of college ever since elementary school. I think it was because she never got to go to college, and she had to work so hard.
“She never made enough money. Lots of nights we just boiled hot dogs for dinner.”
After Ms. Belony was notified about the lawsuit and realized she didn’t have a way to defend herself in court, she contacted the attorney general’s office several times to ask for a lower settlement.
“I was literally begging them; I told them I had no money,” she said. “I tried to ask, could I pay them maybe $500, or just let me finish school, and then I can get enough money to pay them.”
The attorney general’s office finally agreed to a $2,900 settlement, a reduction of around $800, most of which was penalties and fees.
A spokeswoman for the attorney general’s office said it disputed some of Ms. Belony’s assertions but couldn’t comment specifically because of privacy concerns.
After about a year of working at the medical office and searching for a better-paying job, Ms. Belony got hired at a luxury store at Kennedy Airport, where she could earn a sales commission on top of her hourly wage.
For two years, she made the hourlong commute each way and worked as many hours as she could get.
“I didn’t go out, I didn’t buy anything, I just worked and saved,” she said.
In 2019, almost four years after her last class at Plattsburgh, she finally paid off her college debt. A few weeks later, she sat for a three-hour online test and earned the three credits she needed to graduate. She is now trying to repair her credit and take care of her mother, who just had a stroke. She is also enrolled in a master’s degree program at New York University, using what is left of her federal student loans, determined to fulfill her dream of becoming a clinical psychologist.
“I wasn’t sure I was going to make it here. Sometimes I lost hope,” she said, sitting in the Brooklyn apartment she shares with her sister and niece. “But I just kept trying.”
This article was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education.