Bağımsız Güncel Son Dakika Haber Sitesi

How Facebook Failed to Stem Racist Abuse of England’s Soccer Players

In May 2019, Facebook asked the organizing bodies of English soccer to its London offices off Regent’s Park. On the agenda: what to do about the …

How Facebook Failed to Stem Racist Abuse of England’s Soccer Players

In May 2019, Facebook asked the organizing bodies of English soccer to its London offices off Regent’s Park. On the agenda: what to do about the growing racist abuse on the social network against Black soccer players.

At the meeting, Facebook gave representatives from four of England’s main soccer organizations — the Football Association, the Premier League, the English Football League and the Professional Footballers’ Association — what they felt was a brushoff, two people with knowledge of the conversation said. Company executives told the group that they had many issues to deal with, including content about terrorism and child sex abuse.

A few months later, Facebook provided soccer representatives with an athlete safety guide, including directions on how players could shield themselves from bigotry using its tools. The message was clear: It was up to the players and the clubs to protect themselves online.

The interactions were the start of what became a more than two-year campaign by English soccer to pressure Facebook and other social media companies to rein in online hate speech against their players. Soccer officials have since met numerous times with the platforms, sent an open letter calling for change and organized social media boycotts. Facebook’s employees have joined in, demanding that it to do more to stop the harassment.

The pressure intensified after the European Championship last month, when three of England’s Black players were subjected to torrents of racial epithets on social media for missing penalty kicks in the final game’s decisive shootout. Prince William condemned the hate, and the British prime minister, Boris Johnson, threatened regulation and fines for companies that continued to permit racist abuse. Inside Facebook, the incident was escalated to a “Site Event 1,” the equivalent of a companywide five-alarm fire.

Jadon Sancho, who missed a penalty kick during England’s loss in the European Championship final last month, was embraced by the team’s manager, Gareth Southgate.Credit…Pool photo by Laurence Griffiths

Yet as the Premier League, England’s top division, opens its season on Friday, soccer officials said that the social media companies — especially Facebook, the largest — hadn’t taken the issue seriously enough and that players were again steeling themselves for online hate.

“Football is a growing global market that includes clubs, brands, sponsors and fans who are all tired of the obvious lack of desire from the tech giants to develop in-platform solutions for the issues we are dealing with daily,” said Simone Pound, head of equality, diversity and inclusion for the Professional Footballers’ Association, the players’ union.

The impasse with English soccer is another instance of Facebook’s failing to solve speech problems on its platform, even after it was made aware of the level of abuse. While Facebook has introduced some measures to mitigate the harassment, soccer officials said they were insufficient.

Social media companies aren’t doing enough “because the pain hasn’t become enough for them,” said Sanjay Bhandari, the chair of Kick It Out, an organization that supports equality in soccer.

This season, Facebook is trying again. Its Instagram photo-sharing app is expected to roll out new features on Wednesday to make racist material harder to view, according to an internal document obtained by The New York Times. Among them, one will let users hide potentially harassing comments and messages from accounts that either don’t follow or recently followed them.

“The unfortunate reality is that tackling racism on social media, much like tackling racism in society, is complex,” Karina Newton, Instagram’s global head of public policy, said in a statement. “We’ve made important strides, many of which have been driven by our discussions with groups being targeted with abuse, like the U.K. football community.”

But Facebook executives also privately acknowledge that racist speech against English soccer players is likely to continue. “No one thing will fix this challenge overnight,” Steve Hatch, Facebook’s director for Britain and Ireland, wrote last month in an internal note that The Times reviewed.

Some players appear resigned to the abuse. Four days after the European Championship final, Bukayo Saka, 19, one of the Black players who missed penalty kicks for England, posted on Twitter and Instagram that the “powerful platforms are not doing enough to stop these messages” and called it a “sad reality.”

Around the same time, Facebook employees continued to report hateful comments to their employer on Mr. Saka’s posts in an effort to get them taken down. One that was reported — an Instagram comment that read, “Bro stay in Africa” — apparently did not violate the platform’s rules, according to the automated moderation system. It stayed up.

#Enough

Much of the racist abuse in English soccer has been directed at Black superstars in the Premier League, such as Raheem Sterling and Marcus Rashford. About 30 percent of players in the Premier League are Black, Mr. Bhandari said.

Over time, these players have been harassed at soccer stadiums and on Facebook, where users are asked to provide their real names, and on Instagram and Twitter, which allows users to be anonymous. In April 2019, fed up with the behavior, some players and two former captains of the national team, David Beckham and Wayne Rooney, took part in a 24-hour social media boycott, posting red badges on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook with the hashtag #Enough.

A month later, English soccer officials held their first meeting with Facebook — and came away disappointed. Facebook said that “feedback from the meeting was taken on board and influenced further policy, product and enforcement efforts.”

Tensions ratcheted up last year after the police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis. When the Premier League restarted in June 2020 after a 100-day coronavirus hiatus, athletes from all 20 clubs began each match by taking a knee. Players continued the symbolic act last season and said they would also kneel this season.

That has stoked more online abuse. In January, Mr. Rashford used Twitter to call out “humanity and social media at its worst” for the bigoted messages he had received. Two of his Manchester United teammates, who are also Black, were targeted on Instagram with monkey emojis — which are meant to dehumanize — after a loss.

Inside Facebook, employees took note of the surge in racist speech. In one internal forum meant for flagging negative press to the communications department, one employee started cataloging articles about English soccer players who had been abused on Facebook’s platforms. By February, the list had grown to about 20 different news clips in a single month, according to a company document seen by The Times.

Marcus Rashford kneeling in support of the Black Lives Matter movement before a Manchester United match in March.Credit…Peter Powell/Pool Via Reuters

English soccer organizations continued meeting with Facebook. This year, organizers also brought Twitter into the conversations, forming what became known as the Online Hate Working Group.

But soccer officials grew frustrated at the lack of progress, they said. There was no indication that Facebook’s and Twitter’s top leaders were aware of the abuse, said Edleen John, who heads international relations and corporate affairs for the Football Association, England’s governing body for the sport. She and others began discussing writing an open letter to Mark Zuckerberg and Jack Dorsey, the chief executives of Facebook and Twitter.

“Why don’t we try to communicate and get meetings with individuals right at the top of the organization and see if that will make change?” Ms. John said in an interview, explaining the thinking.

In February, the chief executives of the Premier League, the Football Association and other groups published a 580-word letter to Mr. Zuckerberg and Mr. Dorsey accusing them of “inaction” against racial abuse. They demanded that the companies block racist and discriminatory content before it was sent or posted. They also pushed for user identity verification so offenders could be rooted out.

But, Ms. John said, “we didn’t get a response” from Mr. Zuckerberg or Mr. Dorsey. In April, English soccer organizations, players and brands held a four-day boycott of social media.

Twitter, which declined to comment, said in a blog post about racism on Tuesday that it had been “appalled by those who targeted players from the England football team with racist abuse following the Euro 2020 Final.”

Messages of support adorning a mural of Mr. Rashford that was defaced after Italy defeated England for the European championship.Credit…Lindsey Parnaby/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

At Facebook, members of the policy team, which sets the rules around what content stays up or comes down, pushed back against the demands from soccer officials, three people with knowledge of the conversations said.

They argued that terms or symbols used for racist abuse — such as a monkey emoji — could have different meanings depending on the context and should not be banned completely. Identity verification could also undermine anonymity on Instagram and create new problems for users, they argued.

In April, Facebook announced a privacy setting called Hidden Words to automatically filter out messages and comments containing offensive words, phrases and emojis. Those comments cannot then be easily seen by the account user and will be hidden from those who follow the account. A month later, Instagram also began a test that allowed a slice of its users in the United States, South Africa, Brazil, Australia and Britain to flag “racist language or activity,” according to documents reviewed by The Times.

The test generated hundreds of reports. One internal spreadsheet outlining the results included a tab titled “Dehumanization_Monkey/Primate.” It had more than 30 examples of comments using bigoted terms and emojis of monkeys, gorillas and bananas in connection with Black people.

‘The Onus Is on Them’

In the hours after England lost the European Championship final to Italy on July 11, racist comments against the players who missed penalty kicks — Mr. Saka, Mr. Rashford and Jadon Sancho — escalated. That set off a “site event” at Facebook, eventually triggering the kind of emergency associated with a major system outage of the site.

Facebook employees rushed to internal forums to say they had reported monkey emojis or other degrading stereotypes. Some workers asked if they could volunteer to help sort through content or moderate comments for high-profile accounts.

“We get this stream of utter bile every match, and it’s even worse when someone black misses,” one employee wrote on an internal forum.

Gianluigi Donnarumma of Italy stopping Mr. Sancho’s penalty kick. England missed three of five penalty kicks, giving Italy the victory after play ended with the score tied.Credit…Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images

But the employees’ reports of racist speech were often met with automated messages saying the posts did not violated the company’s guidelines. Executives also provided talking points to employees that said Facebook had worked “swiftly to remove comments and accounts directing abuse at England’s footballers.”

In one internal comment, Jerry Newman, Facebook’s director sports partnerships for Europe, the Middle East and Africa, reminded workers that the company had introduced the Hidden Words feature so users could filter out offensive words or symbols. It was the players’ responsibility to use the feature, he wrote.

“Ultimately the onus is on them to go into Instagram and input which emojis/words they don’t want to feature,” Mr. Newman said.

Other Facebook executives said monkey emojis were not typically used negatively. If the company filtered certain terms out for everyone, they added, people might miss important messages.

Adam Mosseri, Instagram’s chief executive, later said the platform could have done better, tweeting in response to a BBC reporter that the app “mistakenly” marked some of the racist comments as “benign.”

Adam Mosseri, head of Instagram, told the BBC that the app had “mistakenly” marked some racist comments as “benign.”Credit…Ricky Rhodes for The New York Times

But Facebook also defended itself in a blog post. The company said it had removed 25 million pieces of hate content in the first three months of the year, while Instagram took down 6.3 million pieces, or 93 percent before a user reported it.

Kelly Hogarth, who helps manage Mr. Rashford’s off-field activities, said he had no plans to leave social media, which serves as an important channel to fans. Still, she questioned how much of the burden should be on athletes to monitor abuse.

“At what point does responsibility come off the player?” she wondered. She added, “I wouldn’t be under any illusions we will be in exactly the same place, having exactly the same conversation next season.”

BU KONUYU SOSYAL MEDYA HESAPLARINDA PAYLAŞ
ZİYARETÇİ YORUMLARI

Henüz yorum yapılmamış. İlk yorumu aşağıdaki form aracılığıyla siz yapabilirsiniz.

BİR YORUM YAZ
bahçe dekorasyonu evde ek gelir eskişehir haber sondakika haberleri magazin haberleri seo sorgulama site analiz seo analiz google sıra bulucu backlink sorgulama sunucu tarama çekiliş çekiliş sitesi Who is html kod şifreleme seo hacklink hacklink satış hacklink panel wordpress ücretsiz tema wordpress free themes wordpress free tema wordpress themes wordpress hacklink al kilo verme wso shell php shell hacklink hacklink panel hızlı seo hacklink seo nedir wso shell instagram takipçi hilesi instagram takipçi hilesi
bahçe dekorasyonu evde ek gelir eskişehir haber sondakika haberleri magazin haberleri seo sorgulama site analiz seo analiz google sıra bulucu backlink sorgulama sunucu tarama çekiliş çekiliş sitesi Who is html kod şifreleme seo hacklink hacklink satış hacklink panel wordpress ücretsiz tema wordpress free themes wordpress free tema wordpress themes wordpress hacklink al kilo verme wso shell php shell hacklink hacklink panel hzlı seo hacklink seo nedir wso shell
backlinkbacklink alwso shellseoankara escortucuz sigarafree shopcamel sigaracaptain blackdjarum blackCavallo SigaraDunhill SigaraHarvest SigaraMarvel sigaraSenator sigaraAl Capone SigaraOme SigaraMarlboro Double FusionMarlboro ShuffleMarlboro TouchMarlboro RedMarlboro TouchMarlboro Edge SlimMarlboro Touch Bluecaptain blackgörükle escortyalova escorthacklink satışhacklinksite analizseo analizhacklink alhacklink nedirbacklinkmini shellmadspot shellwso shell txtBase 64 Encodealfa shellIndoxploit shellindoxploit shellb374k shellphp Mailleradana escortsohbet numaralarıcialis fiyatcialis 20 mgcialis 5 mgcialis 100 mgcialis satışcialis jelcialis siparişcialiscialis nedirviagra fiyatviagra 100 mg fiyatviagraviagra fiyatviagra nedircialis fiyatıcialis jelcialiscialis 5 mgcialis 20 mgcialis 100mggeciktirici spreygeciktiricistag 9000liftanovagravigrandeorcafilflynta 20 mgcombo 100 mgsildegravigrandejeligrasinegralifta 5 mglifta 20 mgdegraviagra 100 mgviagra fiyatıviagra nedirviagra siparişcinsel hastalıklarkamagra jelankara escortmersin escortizmir escortantalya escortadana escortBursa Escortdenizli escortdiyarbakır escorteskişehir escortgaziantep escortistanbul escortkayseri escortkocaeli escortkonya escortkütahya escortmalatya escortsakarya escortsamsun escortsivas escorttekirdağ escorttrabzon escorturfa escortvan escortbodrum escortmarmaris escortfethiye escortkuşadası escortçeşme escortdidim escortbuca escortbornova escortkarşıyaka escortkonak escortalsancak escortaliağa escortgöztepe escortgaziemir escortkarabağlar escortesenyurt escortbeşiktaş escorttuzla escortfatih escortpendik escortbeylikdüzü escortgaziosmanpaşa escortkartal escortbağcılar escortsilivri escortümraniye escortmaltepe escortbeyoğlu escortbahçelievler escortbaşakşehir escortbahçeşehir escortesenler escortüsküdar escortkadıköy escortşişli escortmecidiyeköy escortsarıyer escorttaksim escortetiler escortbebek escortataşehir escortbakırköy escortzeytinburnu escorteyüp escortavcılar escortbüyükçekmece escortkurtköy escortşirinevler escortbayrampaşa escortkasımpaşa escortescortbacklink salesFile Manager shellb374k shellk2ll33d shellBypass shellMadspot shellbedava bonus1xbet girişdert hattıdert hattısohbet hattımersin escortgaziantep escortbedava bonusgaziantep escortGoogle Sıra Bulucupubg hile alSobranie Sigaracaptain blackdjarum blackmarlboro double fusionmarlboro touch blueCavallo Sync MentollüParliament Night Bluewinston dark bluewinston slender bluekent switchkent d range bluecaptain blackmarmaris escortmarvel sigarawinston dark blue fiyatwinston slender bluemarlboro touchparliament night blue fiyatcaptain blackmarlboro double fusionolmeca tekila fiyatdjarum blackheets sigaraparliament reservemonte cristo habanacamel sigarakent switch fiyatlucky strikefree shopmarlboro touch blue fiyatmarlboro double fusionmarlboro goldharvest sigarar57 shellalfa shellcaptain blackmarvel sigarawinston dark bluemarlboro touch blueparliament night blue fiyatcavallo sigaramarlboro double fusionVogue Frissonadana escortparliament night blue fiyatafyon escortaydın escortbalıkesir escortbolu escortçanakkale escortedirne escortelazığ escorterzurum escorthatay escortısparta escortmanisa escortmaraş escortmardin escortmuğla escortmuş escortrize escorttunceli escortuşak escortyozgat escorttokat escortzonguldak escortaksaray escortyalova escortağrı escortamasya escortalanya escortmanavgat escortankara escortantalya escortbursa escortdenizli escortdiyarbakır escorteskişehir escortgaziantep escortistanbul escortizmir escortkayseri escortkocaeli escortkonya escortkütahya escortmalatya escortmersin escortsakarya escortsamsun escortsivas escorttekirdağ escorttrabzon escorturfa escortvan escortmarmaris escortbodrum escortfethiye escortkuşadası escortçeşme escortdidim escortbuca escortbornova escortkarşıyaka escortkonak escortalsancak escortaliağa escortgaziemir escortkarabağlar escortesenyurt escortbeşiktaş escorttuzla escortfatih escortpendik escortbeylikdüzü escortgaziosmanpaşa escortkartal escortbağcılar escortsilivri escortümraniye escortmaltepe escortbeyoğlu escortbahçelievler escortbaşakşehir escortbahçeşehir escortesenler escortüsküdar escortkadıköy escortşişli escortmecidiyeköy escortsarıyer escorttaksim escortetiler escortbebek escortataşehir escortbakırköy escortzeytinburnu escorteyüp escortavcılar escortbüyükçekmece escortkurtköy escortşirinevler escortbayrampaşa escorthalkalı escortafyon escortaydın escortbalıkesir escortbolu escortçanakkale escortedirne escortelazığ escorterzurum escorthatay escortısparta escortmanisa escortmaraş escortmardin escortmuğla escortmuş escortrize escorttunceli escortuşak escortyozgat escorttokat escortzonguldak escortaksaray escortyalova escortağrı escortamasya escortalanya escortmanavgat escortsincan escortwso shellwso green shellJagermeisterKeno Club Sigarayalova escortşişli bayan escortşişli escortistanbul escortgörükle escortistanbul escortmecidiyeköy escortşişli escortkurtköy escortsosyal ablagaziantep escortlarısohbet hattısohbet hatlarısohbet numaralarıkent d range blueMelbetpendik escortcamel sigaraparliament night blue fiyatvotka fiyatlarımarlboro double fusionviagra fiyatcaptain blackçam balı faydalarıçam balı nedirtuzla escortaydınlı escortorhanlı escorttepeoren escortyalova escortbursa escortgorukle escortbursa escort bayanbursa sinirsiz escortbursa escortescort bayanaltiparmak escortnilüfer escortotele gelen escortbursa merkez escortbursa merkez escortbursa escortescort bayanaltiparmak escortbursa eve gelen escortbursa otele gelen escortbursa sınırsız escortgörükle escortescort bursatuzla escorttuzla escort bayanwhmcs killer v4bodrum escortbodrum escortbodrum escortbayrampaşa escortbeşiktaş escortçağlayan escorttaksim escortbakırköy escortistanbul escortgüngören escortkasımpaşa escortkaynarca escortesenyurt escortistanbul escortacıbadem escortadalar escortadapazarı escortalibeyköy escortaltınşehir escortanadoluhisarı escortanal escortarnavutköy escortatakent escortbahariye escortbahçeköy escortbahçelievler escortbalmumcu escortbaşakşehir escortantalya escort bayanbebek escortbebek escortataşehir escortbeyazıt escortbeykoy escortbeyoğlu escortbomonti escortbüyükdere escortcaddebostan escortçapa escortçengelköy escortcevizlibağ escortcihangir escortçubuklu escortdragos escortedirnekapı escortkurtköy escorteminönü escortankara escortavcılar escortgebze escorthalkalı escortşişli escorteve gelen escorteyüp escortfenerbahçe escortfeneryolu escortfikirtepe escortfındıklı escortfındıkzade escortflorya escortfulya escortgalata escortgrup escortgulhane escortgulsuyu escortharbiye escortharem escortharem escorthasanpaşa escortincirli escortıspartakule escortistanbul escortistanbul escortkabataş escortdjarum blackolimpbet kzmarlboro double fusionlifta 20 mglifta 5 mgdegraorcafilviagra hapviagra siparişviagra fiyatıviagra satışviagraeczacıbaşı viagra fiyatlarıviagra siparişviagra fiyatıdjarum blackyalova escortçınarcık escortsertleştirici hap çeşitlerisertleştirici hap yorumlarıeczanede satılan cinsel güç ilaçlarısertleştirici hap isimlericinsel hap isimlericinsel gücü artıran ilaçlarpenis sertleştirici hap çeşitlericinsel güç artırıcı ilaç isimleriereksiyon hapı isimlerisertleştirici ilaç isimlerişişme bebek çeşitlericinsel güç arttırıcı hap isimlerieczanede satılan cinsel ilaç isimlerien iyi performans arttırıcı ilaç isimleribayan istek arttırıcı damla çeşitleribayan azdırıcı hap çeşitlericinsel güç arttırıcı hap çeşitleridjarum blacksertleştirici hap markalarıpenis sertleştirici ilaç çeşitlerisertleşmeye en iyi ilaçcinsel ilaç isimlerierkek cinsel gücü arttırıcı ilaç çeşitlericaptain blackcinsel gücü artıran ilaç fiyatlarıcinsel güç arttırıcı ilaç yorumlarıeczanede satılan cinsel gücü arttıran ilaç isimleriereksiyon sağlayıcı ilaç çeşitlericinsel güç arttırıcı ilaçcinsel gücü arttıran ilaç markalarıen iyi geciktirici hap isimlerien iyi geciktirici sprey çeşitlerimarlboro double fusioncamel sigaracinsel gücü artıran ilaç incelemeleridjarum blacksertleşmeye iyi gelen ilaç isimlerimarlboro goldeczanede satılan viagrawinston lightwinston dark blueMarlboro Touch Graycinsel güç arttırıcı macuncaptain black bluenovagra geciktirici hapolmeca tekilaeczane cialis fiyatıBackwoods Islak Purocialis satın alerkek azdırıcı damlaviagra satış fiyatıerkek azdırıcı hap isimleriwinston dark blue fiyatiçmeler escorttepeören escortaydınlı escortorhanlı escortyalova escortfree shopsex hikayependik escortyalova escortgörükle escortçınarcık escortkartal escorttuzla escortpendik escortmaltepe escortbostancı escortataşehir escortdjarum blackabana haberagrı habertunceli haberafyon haberkartal escortşişli escortşişli escort bayankurtkoy escorttuzla escortsoundtracker.fmsoundtracker.fmsoundtracker.fmsoundtracker.fmsoundtracker.fm/bnsoundtracker.fm/en/mecidiyeköy escortEn İyi Geciktirici Hap İsimleri ve ÇeşitleriCinsel Gücü Artıran Macun İsimlerikent slim blackchivas regalyeşil perişişli bayan escortsisli bayan escortşişli bayan escortsisli bayan escortsincan eescortKolej escortDikmen escortBalgat escortÇankaya escortCebeci escortDemetevler escortKızılay escortKeçiören escortEtlik escortEtimesgut escortEryaman escortYenimahalle escortOtele gelen escortRus escortankara rus escortAnkara escortEtlik escortKeçiören escortAnkara escortAnkara escortEryaman escortAnkara escortÇankaya escortmersin escortBalgat escortBeşevler escortÇankaya escortCebeci escortDikmen escortDemetevler escortEryaman escortEtimesgut escortEtlik escortKeçiören escortKızılay escortKolej escortMaltepe escortOtele gelen escortRus escortYenimahalle escortDikmen escortElvankent escortSincan escortşişli escortistanbul escort bayanmecidiyeköy escortbetwinnerçorumsporslotticasoundtracker.fm/bn/melbet-casino/teknoloji haberlerihaberlerson dakika haberleriekonomi haberlerihaberlerslottywaymostbet saytiantalya escortmostbetlondon escortsescorts agencyescorts in londonlondon escort girlsbetwinnerSex hikayeSeks HikayeleriEnsest hikayeleradana escortadıyaman escortafyon escortağrı escortaksaray escortamasya escortankara escortantalya escortantep escortardahan escortartvin escortaydın escortbalıkesir escortbartın escortbatman escortSeks erotik hikayeSikiş hikayeleribayburt escortbilecik escortbingöl escortbitlis escortbolu escortburdur escortbursa escortçanakkale escortçankırı escortçorum escortdenizli escortdiyarbakır escortdüzce escortedirne escortelazığ escorterzincan escorterzurum escorteskişehir escortgiresun escortgümüşhane escorthakkari escorthatay escortığdır escortısparta escortistanbul escortizmir escortizmit escortkarabük escortkaraman escortkars escortkastamonu escortkayseri escortkıbrıs escortkilis escortkırıkkale escortkırklareli escortkırşehir escortkocaeli escortkonya escortkütahya escortmalatya escortmanisa escortmaraş escortmardin escortmersin escortmuğla escortmuş escortnevşehir escortniğde escortordu escortosmaniye escortrize escortsakarya escortsamsun escortsiirt escortsinop escortşırnak escortsivas escorttekirdağ escorttokat escorttrabzon escorttunceli escortzonguldak escorturfa escortuşak escortvan escortyalova escortyozgat escortmostbetuz.liveviagra eczane satışcialis eczane satışpenis sertleştirici hap isimleri ve çeşitleripenis sertleştirici cinsel haplarbursa escortbursa escortgorukle escortşişli escortşişli rus escortşişli iranlı escortşişli escortnilüfer escortyalova escortyalova escortyalova escort bayankurtuluş escortseobridge istanbulkapı doktorufotoselli kapıdöner kapıepoksiKamagra jelCialis fiyatvega 100 mgViagra fiyatViagra fiyat 2022Cinsel ilaçlarCinsel sağlık ilaçlarıVega 100 mg fiyatVega 100 mgkamagra jelCialis 100 mg fiyatcialis fiyatcobra 130 mgViagra eczaneCialis eczaneKamagra jel eczanelevitra fiyatVega 100 mg eczaneCinsel performans artırıcı ilaçlarBayan azdırıcı damlaGeciktirici spreyviagra fiyatviagra satışcinsel eczaneonline eczanecinsel ilaçlarzayıflamakamagraviagrapenis büyütmeViagra 30 lu fiyatOrijinal viagraViagra 4 lü tablet fiyaterken boşalma tedaviOrijinal viagra 4 lü fiyatKamagra jel fiyatereksiyon haplarıkadın azdırıcıafrodizyak parfümlerEreksiyon haplarıCobra 130 mg kırmızı tabletcialis eczanesertleştirici haplar eczaneKamagra jel yorumlarıbayan azdırıcılarerkek azdırıcıLevitra fiyatgeciktirici spreyLevitra 20 mg fiyatcialis siparişLady era bayan viagrası azdırıcı hapviagra eczanebayan azdırıcı eczaneistek arttırıcı damlacinsel güç arttırıcı ilaçlareczanelerde satılan geciktiricilerKamagrakamagra fiyatCinsel ürünlerorjinal viagraViagra 30 tabletAfrodizyak etkili azdırıcı parfümlercialis 5 mgviagra 30 lu fiyatviagra 4 lü tabletcialis 4 lü tabletviagra 30 lu tabletcialis 100 mgcinsel eczaneepoksi zemin kaplamasertleştirici hap eczanecinsel güç arttırıcı sertleştirici happenis sertleştirici ilaç ve haplarpenis sertleştirici cinsel hapeczanelerde satılan cinsel gücü artıran ilaçcialis satışı ve siparişibridge istanbulhasta yatağıoscar sigaraMagic london escortsindependent london escortsDubai hot escortEscort girl dubaişişli escortşişli escort bayanyalova escortyalova escort bayanviagracialis 20 mg eczane fiyatıcialis 5 mg fiyatbayan azdırıcıbayan istek arttırıcılady erabayan azdırıcı damlabayan istek arttırıcı damlaviagrakalbe zarar vermeyen sertleştiriciviagracialis fiyatcialis fiyatıcialis fiyatlarıcialis satışcialis siparişcialis satın alcialis 100 mgcialis 5 mgcialiscialis 20 mgcialis jelviagra fiyatviagra fiyatıviagra satışviagra siparişviagraviagra 100 mgviagra kremmecidiyeköy escortataköy escortavcılar escortbakırköy escortesenyurt escortşişli escorttaksim escortbeşiktaş escortşişli escortbodrum escortizmir escortyalova escortyalova otele gelen escortyalova eve gelen escortaksaray escortatakent escortataköy escortataköy eve gelen escortataköy masöz escortataköy-otele-gelen-escortataköy rus escortataköy türbanlı escortataköy ucuz escortataköy üniversiteli escortataşehir escortavcılar escortavcılar eve gelen escortavcılar masöz escortavcılar otele gelen escortavcılar rus escortavcılar türbanlı escortavcılar ucuz escortavcılar üniversiteli escortavrupa yakası escortbağdat caddesi escortbahçelievler escortbahçesehir escortbakırköy üniversiteli escortbakırköy escortbakırköy eve gelen escortbakırköy masöz escortbakırköy otele gelen escortbakırköy rus escortbakırköy türbanlı escortbakırköy ucuz escortbaşakşehir escortbeşiktaş escortbeşyol escortbeykent escortbeylikdüzü escortbeylikdüzü eve gelen escortbeylikdüzü masöz escortbeylikdüzü otele gelen escortbeylikdüzü rus escortbeylikdüzü türbanlı escortbeylikdüzüucuz escortbeylikdüzü üniversiteli escortbeyoğlu escortbizimkent escortbostancı escortbüyükcekmece escortesenyurt escortesenyurt eve gelen escortesenyurt otele gelen escortesenyurt rus escortesenyurt turbanlı escortesenyurt ucuz escortesenyurt üniversiteli escortetiler escorteve gelen escortfatih escorthalkalı escorthalkalı eve gelen escorthalkalı masöz escorthalkalı otele gelen escorthalkalı rus escorthalkalı türbanlı escorthalkalı ucuz escorthalkalı üniversiteli escortharamidere escortinnovia escortistanbul escortkadıköy escortkağıthane escortkartal escortküçükçekmece escortmaltepe escortmecidiyeköy escortmerter escortotele gelen escortpendik escortrus escortsarıyer escortsefaköy escortsilivri escortşirinevler escortşirinevler türbanlışirinevler ucuzşişli escortsınırsız escorttaksim escorttesettürlü escorttopkapı escorttürbanlı escorttüyap escortucuz escortümraniye escortüniversiteli öğrenci escortyabancı escortyenibosna escortzeytinburnu escortsmm panelgaziantep escortmersin escortpostegroweb postegroweb postegroalanya escortbodrum escortdidim escortfethiye escortkuşadası escortmanavgat escortmarmaris escorteczane sertleşme haplarıyapay kızlık zarıkaynarca escortatalar escortcevizli escortEscorts İn BodrumBodrum Bayan Escortpostegropostegroweb postegroizmit escortkocaeli escortizmit escortkocaeli escortgebze escortgölcük escortdarica escortizmit otele gelen escortizmit eve gelen escortkocaeli evi olan escortotele gelen escortizmit sınırsız escortcialis 20 mg fiyatcialis 100 mg fiyatcialis 5 mg fiyatviagra 100 mg fiyatcialis 5 mg fiyatcialis fiyat eczanepostegropostegrocinsel hastalıklarereksiyon sorunuacarkent escortbahariye escortcialis 20 mgcialis 100 mgcialis 5 mgcialis fiyatcialiscialis fiyatlarıviagra fiyatviagra siparişcialis satışcialis siparişviagra fiyatlarıkartal escortbedava bonus veren bahis siteleribahisgaziantep escortviagraviagra fiyatpostegropostegropostegroDubai escortsDubai escortsLondon escortsfree instagram followersMarmaris Escortpendik escortkartal escortkurtkoy escorttuzla escorthalkalı escortbayrampaşa escortbaşakşehir escortbahçelievler escortbağcılar escortbahçeşehir escortkadın giyimfantezi babydollfantezi çorapfantezi giyimKadın üst giyimkadın alt giyimkadın ayakkabıkadın atletbluz bodybot bootiekadın ceketkadın çizmekadın elbiseelbise abiyekadın eşofman altıkadın eşofman takımıAnkara escort bayanturgutreis escortpostegroweb postegroweb postegropostegroizmit escortistanbul escortkaynarca escortviagra 100 mg fiyatviagra 100 mg fiyatgaziantep escort bayanGüvenilir bahis SiteleriBalgat escortÇankaya escortCebeci escortDemetevler escortDikmen escortEryaman escortEsat escortEtlik escortKeçiören escortKızılay escortKolej escortRus escortSincan escortYenimahalle escortAtaşehir escortanadolu yakası escortAnadolu yakası escortAtaşehir escortAtaşehir escortKadıköy escortKadıköy escortÜmraniye escortÜmraniye escortBostancı escortBostancı escortbostancı escortpostegroadana escortadana escort bayanafyon escortacarkent escortacibadem escortadalar escortafyon escortalanya escort bayanalanya escortantalya escort bayanantalya escortartvin escortartvin escortbeylikdüzü escortbeylikdüzü escortbeylikdüzü escortbeylikdüzü escortbodrum escortbolu escortbolu escortburdur escortbursa escortbursa escortçanakkale escortçanakkale escortçeşme escortdidim escortdiyarbakır escortdiyarbakır escortedirne escortedirne escortelazığ escortelazığ escorterzincan escorterzincan escorterzurum escorterzurum escortbodrum escortbursa escortbursa escorteskişehir escorteskişehir escortgaziantep escortgaziantep escortgaziantep escortgiresun escortgiresun escortgümüşhane escorthatay escorthatay escortısparta escortısparta escortkars escortkastamonu escortkastamonu escortkayseri escortkayseri escortkıbrıs escortkıbrıs escortkonya escortkonya escortkuşadası escortkütahya escortkütahya escortmalatya escortmalatya escortmanisa escortmanisa escortmardin escortmardin escortmarmaris escortmersin escortnevşehir escortnevşehir escortniğde escortniğde escortordu escortordu escortrize escortrize escortsakarya escortsakarya escortsamsun escortsamsun escortşanlıurfa escortşanlıurfa escortsinop escortsinop escortsivas escortsivas escorttekirdağ escorttekirdağ escorttrabzon escorttrabzon escortuşak escortvan escortvan escortyalova escortyalova escortyozgat escortyozgat escortzonguldak escortzonguldak escortCoinbar girişSafirbet girişcratosslot girişAsyabahis girişTempobet girişMarsbahis girişBetebet girişVdcasino girişVevobahis girişBetper girişimajbet girişHoliganbet girişJojobet girişAnadolucasino girişArtemisbet girişbelugabahis girişbetvole girişinterbahis girişmilanobet girişZeytinburnu EscortYeşilköy EscortYenibosna EscortÜmraniye EscortTopkapı EscortTaksim EscortSuadiye EscortSınırsız EscortŞişman EscortŞişli EscortŞirinevler EscortSilivri EscortPendik EscortOrtaköy EscortOlgun EscortNişantaşı EscortMerter EscortMecidiyeköy EscortMaslak EscortMaltepe EscortMahmutbey EscortLevent EscortKurtköy EscortKüçükyalı EscortKüçükçekmece EscortKartal EscortKağıthane EscortKadıköy Escortİstanbul Escortİkitelli EscortHaramidere EscortHalkalı EscortGöztepe EscortGenç EscortFlorya EscortFındıkzade EscortFatih EscortEtiler EscortEsenyurt EscortEscort NumaralarıEscort BayanlarErenköy EscortElit Escortçekmeköy escortÇıtır Escortşerifali escortCihangir Escortümraniye escortüsküdar escortCevizli EscortCennet Mahallesi Escortsuadiye escortÇapa Escortkadıköy escortÇağlayan Escortgöztepe escortBüyükçekmece Escortbostancı escortgöztepe escortBostancı EscortBeyoğlu Escortsuadiye escorterenköy escortbostancı escortanadolu yakası escortavrupa yakası escortBeylikdüzü EscortBeşiktaş Escortanadolu yakası escortBayrampaşa EscortBaşakşehir Escortümraniye escortBakırköy Escortkadıköy escortBahçelievler Escortbostancı escortBağdat Caddesi Escortataşehir escortBağcılar Escortcevizli escortatalar escortmaltepe escortAvrupa Yakası Escortkartal escortmaltepe escortAvcılar EscortAtaşehir Escortümraniye escortsupertotobetrestbet girisbetpas girisbetbabayurtdisiaugenoperationbotox bruisinghepsibahisrexbetsuperbetinbetsatbets10romabettarafbetbetparkhilbetonbahisbahsegelbahigowinxbetelitbahisdinamobetbetmatiktimebetgebze escortleopard honeyAnkara escortUlus escortTunalı escortTandoğan escortSıhhiye escortRus escortMamak escortMamak escortGölbaşı escortCinsel sağlık ürünleriCinsel performans ilaçlarıCialis fiyatCialis 20 mg fiyatCialis 100 mg fiyatCialis 30 lu tablet fiyatViagra fiyatViagra 100 mg fiyatViagra 30 lu fiyatViagra 4 lü tablet fiyatıVega 100 mgVega 100 mg fiyatVega 100 mg eczaneKamagra jelKamagra Jel fiyatKamagra jel eczaneSertleştirici haplarGeciktirici ürünlercialiscinsel sağlık ürünleribayan azdırıcı fiyatkadın azdırıcı damlasertleştirici ilaçlarcialis fiyatviagra fiyatpenis büyütücükamagra jelgeciktirici spreycialis 20 mgcialis 100 mgviagra 30 luen iyi penis sertleştirici ilaçsertleştirici haplarelazığ escort bayanhasta yataklarıkent switch fiyatKeno Club Sigaraparliament aqua bluemarlboro double fusionGauloises Sigarakent switchdjarum blackLeader SigaraAnadolu yakası escortAtaşehir escortBostancı escortErenköy Escortavrupa yakası escortAtaköy EscortAvcılar EscortBahçeşehir Escortözel escortlaranal escortçıtır escortelit escortAnadolu Yakası escortAtaşehir escortbağdat caddesi escortBostancı escortGöztepe Escortİstanbul EscortKadıköy EscortKartal EscortKurtköy EscortMaltepe EscortPendik EscortŞerifali EscortTuzla EscortÜmraniye escortÜsküdar EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortAtaşehir escortBostancı EscortGöztepe EscortAvrupa Yakası EscortAksaray escortAtaköy EscortAvcılar Escortİstanbul EscortAtaşehir Elit EscortAtaşehir Esmer EscortAtaşehir Genç EscortAtaşehir Olgun EscortAtaşehir Sarışın EscortAtaşehir Şişman EscortAtaşehir Sınırsız EscortAtaşehir Ucuz EscortAtaşehir Yabancı EscortAteşehir Escort BayanBağdat Caddesi EscortBağdat Caddesi Olgun EscortBağdat Caddesi Sarışın EscortBağdat Caddesi Şişman EscortBağdat Caddesi Ucuz EscortBağdat Caddesi Yabancı EscortBostancı Elit EscortBostancı Çıtır EscortBostancı EscortBostancı Esmer EscortBostancı Olgun EscortBostancı Sarışın EscortBostancı Yabancı EscortGöztepe EscortGöztepe Genç EscortGöztepe Olgun EscortGöztepe Şişman EscortGöztepe Sınırsız EscortGöztepe Ucuz EscortKadıköy Anal EscortKadıköy Elit EscortKadıköy EscortKadıköy Eskort BayanlarKadıköy Genç EscortKadıköy Yabancı EscortKartal Çıtır EscortKartal EscortKartal Eskort BayanlarKartal Esmer EscortKartal Sarışın EscortKartal Sınırsız EscortKartal Ucuz EscortKaynarca EscortKaynarca Genç EscortKaynarca Olgun EscortKaynarca Şişman EscortKurtköy EscortKurtköy Escort BayanKurtköy Ucuz EscortKurtköy Yabancı Escort BayanMaltepe Anal EscortMaltepe EscortMaltepe Genç EscortMaltepe Olgun EscortMaltepe Şişman EscortPendik EskortPendik Eskort BayanlarPendik Sarışın EscortPendik Şişman EscortPendik Sınırsız EscortPendik Ucuz EscortTuzla Anal EscortTuzla Elit EscortTuzla EscortTuzla Yabancı EscortÜmraniye EscortÜmraniye Masöz EscortÜmraniye Olgun EscortÜmraniye Ucuz Escortepoksi zeminepoksi zemin kaplamaepoksi yol çizgisişişli escortAcıbadem Escortİçerenköy EscortKozyatağı EscortKüçükyalı EscortKadıköy EscortKartal EscortMaltepe EscortPendik EscortKurtköy EscortŞerifali EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortKadıköy EscortAtaşehir EscortBostancı EscortAtaşehir EscortKadıköy EscortKurtköy EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortAtaşehir EscortBostancı EscortKadıköy EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortKadıköy EscortAtaşehir EscortBostancı EscortMaltepe EscortGöztepe EscortPendik EscortErenköy EscortGöztepe EscortSuadiye EscortGöztepe EscortMaltepe EscortŞerifali EscortKartal EscortKurtköy EscortPendik EscortKurtköy EscortPendik EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortKartal EscortMaltepe EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortKartal Escort BayanKurtköy Escort BayanMaltepe Escort BayanPendik Escort BayanAnadolu Yakası EscortKartal EscortKurtköy EscortMaltepe EscortPendik EscortTuzla EscortKurtköy EscortPendik EscortTuzla EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortMaltepe EscortKartal EscortBostancı EscortÜmraniye EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortKadıköy EscortAtaşehir EscortTuzla EscortGebze EscortAydınlı EscortMutlukent EscortPendik EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortKurtköy EscortÜmraniye EscortBostancı EscortKartal Escort BayanPendik Escort BayanKurtköy Escort BayanMaltepe EscortAnadolu Yakası EscortBostancı EscortKartal EscortMaltepe EscortÜmraniye Escortbağdat caddesi escortgöztepe escortistanbul escortkartal escortkurtköy escortmaltepe escortpendik escorttuzla escortüsküdar escortataköy escortavcılar escort bayanavrupa yakası escortbahçeşehir escortbakırköy escortbeşiktaş escortbeylikdüzü escorterenköy escortetiler escortgöztepe escortikitelli escortkartal escortkurtköy escortmaltepe escortmecidiyeköy escortpendik escortşirinevler escortşişli escortsoğanlık escortataşehir escortkaynarca escortümraniye escortgebze escorttuzla escortavrupa yakası escortavrupa yakası escortavrupa yakası escortavrupa yakası escortavrupa yakası escortavrupa yakası escortavrupa yakası escortavrupa yakası escortavrupa yakası escortatalar escortcevizli escortescort bayanmaltepe escortbeylikdüzü escortavcılar escortesenyurt escortbahçeşehir escortşirinevler escortataköy escortbeylikduzuescortev.comescort beylikdüzüWhatsapp aerobeylikdüzü eskortbahariye escortmoda escortsex hikayeleriadana escortadıyaman escortafyon escortağrı escortaksaray escortamasya escortankara escortantalya escortantep escortardahan escortartvin escortaydın escortbalıkesir escortbartın escortbatman escortbayburt escortbilecik escortbingol escortbitlis escortbolu escortburdur escortbursa escortçanakkale escortçankırı escortçorum escortdenizli escortdiyarbakır escortdüzce escortedirne escortelazığ escorterzincan escorterzurum escorteskişehir escortgiresun escortgümüşhane escorthakkari escorthatay escortığdır escortısparta escortistanbul escortizmir escortizmit escortkarabük escortkaraman escortkars escortkastamonu escortkayseri escortkıbrıs escortkilis escortkırıkkale escortkırklareli escortkırşehir escortkocaeli escortkonya escortkütahya escortmalatya escortmanisa escortmaraş escortmardin escortmersin escortmuğla escortmuş escortnevşehir escortniğde escortordu escortosmaniye escortrize escortsakarya escortsamsun escortsiirt escortsinop escortşırnak escortsivas escorttekirdağ escorttokat escorttrabzon escorttunceli escortzonguldak escorturfa escortuşak escortvan escortyalova escortyozgat escorterkeklerde sertleşmeye iyi gelen ilaçlarsertleştirici hap eczane fiyatlarıyakacik escortsisli escortvega 100 mg hapseofuck googledolandırıcı hesap satışıviagrabacklink almetin2 pvppvp metin2metin2emek serveradana escortadana escortanadolu yakasi escortpendik escortistanbul escort